Introductory Signals
So while doing some background reading today I realized that legal citations already widely support a form of "citation typing" in the form of "Introductory Signals". The 10 introductory signals break down as follows...
In support of an argument:
1) [no signal]. (NB that, apparently, this is increasingly deprecated.)
2) accord;
3) see;
4) see also;
5) cf.;
For Comparisons:
6) compare ... with ...;
For contradiction:
7) but see;
8) but cf.;
For background:
9) see generally;
And for examples:
10) e.g.
Clever lawyers.

Comments
Cool that these are formalized in lawyers' citation styles! I spent a little time tracking down some references so I'll share them here:
http://www.law.suffolk.edu/library/research/Bluebook/signals.cfm
http://www.law.cornell.edu/citation/6-300.htm
The other question: has anybody done a citation or argumentation analysis on a legal corpus, relying on this data?
Posted by: Jodi Schneider | May 9, 2010 3:13 PM