Reply to the comment on “First records of syn-diagenetic non-tectonic folding in Quaternary thermogene travertines caused by hydrothermal incremental veining” by Billi et alii
Graphical abstract
Introduction
We thank Alcicek et alii for bringing their opinion to our attention and welcome their comments that allow us to further detail our arguments. We begin our reply by synthesizing and better explaining our main results together with some instructive additions. We then reply to the main comments raised by Alcicek et alii and finally conclude with some general inferences.
The travertine exposures addressed in this paper belong to the Pleistocene Pianetti and Pian di Palma deposits, which are located in Tuscany, central Italy, at 42° 38′ 00.52″N and 11° 30′ 40.43″E, and 42° 41′ 21.15″N and 11° 29′ 52.79″E, respectively. The geological setting of these deposits is described in Carmignani et al. (2013), Berardi et al. (2016), Vignaroli et al. (2016), and Billi et al. (2017), whereas the origin and genetic context of Quaternary travertines from central Italy are described in Chiodini et al. (1995), Minissale et al. (2002), and Minissale (2004).
Section snippets
Rationale
Since thermogene travertines are more and more often used as (temporal) indicators of climate change, active faulting, and other environmental processes (Rihs et al., 2000, Minissale et al., 2002, Pentecost, 2005, Crossey et al., 2006, Crossey et al., 2009, Uysal et al., 2007, Uysal et al., 2009, Dockrill and Shipton, 2010, De Filippis and Billi, 2012, De Filippis et al., 2013, Kampman et al., 2012, Burnside et al., 2013, Sinisi et al., 2016), in our previous paper (Billi et al., 2017):
- (1)
We
Organization
In this section, we summarize some of Alcicek et alii's main comments and briefly reply, with the aid of a few figures, to each of them under three main thematic sub-sections.
Primary crystalline crusts vs. secondary mineralizations
Alcicek et alii stated that we did not recognize primary crystalline crusts, thus erroneously interpreting them as secondary mineralizations. We are aware of and did not challenge at all the fact that fan-shaped calcite crystals in thermogene travertines can be primary features (crystalline crusts in Guo and Riding, 1998).
Conclusions
The comments by Alcicek et alii, although welcome, do not alter our previous conclusions (Billi et al., 2017), which we synthetically re-propose here.
Since thermogene travertines are more and more often used as (temporal) indicators of climate change, active faulting, and further environmental processes, in Billi et al. (2017):
- (1)
We warned that the common stratigraphic concept of travertine registering sedimentary succession with age younging from bottom to top is not always correct.
- (2)
We then
Acknowledgments
Institutional funding from Roma Tre University, CNR-IGAG, Hungarian Academy of Sciences (János Bolyai scholarship to S.K.), Hungarian Scientific Research Fund (OTKA 101664), ETH Zürich, and ISTerre Grenoble are acknowledged. Dating at the HISPEC was supported by the Taiwan ROC MOST grants (105-2119-M-002-001 to CCS), and National Taiwan University (105R7625 to CCS). We acknowledge, in particular, no industrial funding for this study. We warmly thank P. Agard and an anonymous reviewer for
References (40)
- et al.
Growth of a Pleistocene giant carbonate vein and nearby thermogene travertine deposits at Semproniano, southern Tuscany, Italy: estimate of CO2 leakage
Tectonophysics
(2016) Solution slip and separations on strike-slip fault zones: theory and application to the Mattinata Fault, Italy
J. Struct. Geol.
(2003)- et al.
First records of syn-diagenetic folding in Quaternary thermogene travertines caused by hydrothermal incremental veining
Tectonophysics
(2017) - et al.
Deep structures and carbon dioxide degassing in central Italy
Geothermics
(1995) - et al.
The origin and growth of a recently-active fissure ridge travertine over a seismic fault, Tivoli, Italy
Geomorphology
(2013) - et al.
Structural controls on leakage from a natural CO2 geologic storage site: Central Utah, U.S.A
J. Struct. Geol.
(2010) - et al.
Late Pleistocene depositional cycles of the Lapis Tiburtinus travertine (Tivoli, Central Italy): possible influence of climate and fault activity
Glob. Planet. Chang.
(2008) - et al.
Mineral growth in rocks: kinetic-rheological models of replacement, vein formation, and syntectonic crystallization
Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta
(2001) - et al.
Geochemical transect through a travertine mount: a detailed record of CO2-enriched fluid leakage from Late Pleistocene to present-day – Little Grand Wash fault (Utah, USA)
Quat. Int.
(2017) - et al.
On the arrangement of solid inclusions in fibrous veins and the role of the crack-seal mechanism
J. Struct. Geol.
(2005)