Abstract
This field study tested the hypothesis that domestic horses living under putatively challenging-to-welfare conditions (for example involving social, spatial, feeding constraints) would present signs of poor welfare and co-occurring pessimistic judgement biases. Our subjects were 34 horses who had been housed for over 3 years in either restricted riding school situations (e.g. kept in single boxes, with limited roughage, ridden by inexperienced riders; N = 25) or under more naturalistic conditions (e.g. access to free-range, kept in stable social groups, leisure riding; N = 9). The horses’ welfare was assessed by recording health-related, behavioural and postural indicators. Additionally, after learning a location task to discriminate a bucket containing either edible food (‘positive’ location) or unpalatable food (‘negative’ location), the horses were presented with a bucket located near the positive position, near the negative position and halfway between the positive and negative positions to assess their judgement biases. The riding school horses displayed the highest levels of behavioural and health-related problems and a pessimistic judgment bias, whereas the horses living under more naturalistic conditions displayed indications of good welfare and an optimistic bias. Moreover, pessimistic bias data strongly correlated with poor welfare data. This suggests that a lowered mood impacts a non-human species’ perception of its environment and highlights cognitive biases as an appropriate tool to assess the impact of chronic living conditions on horse welfare.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson MH, Hardcastl C, Munafò MR, Robinson ESJ (2012) Evaluation of a novel translational task for assessing emotional biases in different species. Cogn Affect Behav Ne 12:373–381
Arnaud G, Dubroeucq H, Rivot D (1997) Notation de l’état corporel des chevaux de selle et de sport. Inra, Institut du cheval - Institut de l’Elevage, Paris
Ashley FH, Waterman-Pearson AE, Whay HR (2005) Behavioural assessment of pain in horses and donkeys: application to clinical practice and future studies. Equine Vet J 37:565–575
Bachmann I, Audigé L, Stauffacher M (2003) Risk factors associated with the occurrence of behavioural disorders cribbing, weaving and box-walking in Swiss horses. Equine Vet J 35:158–163
Baciadonna L, McElligott AG (2015) The use of judgement bias to assess welfare in farm livestock. Anim Welf 24:81–91
Bateson M, Matheson SM (2007) Performance on a categorisation task suggests that removal of environmental enrichment induces ‘pessimism’ in captive European starlings (Sturnus vulgaris). Anim Welf 16:33–36
Bateson M, Nettle D (2015) Development of a cognitive bias methodology for measuring low mood in chimpanzees. Peer J PrePrints 3:e1285. doi:10.7287/peerj.preprints.888v2
Bateson M, Desire S, Gartside SE, Wright GA (2011) Agitated honeybees exhibit pessimistic cognitive bias. Curr Biol 21:1070–1073
Bateson M, Emmerson M, Ergün G, Monaghan P, Nettle D (2015) Opposite effects of early-life competition and developmental telomere attrition on cognitive biases in juvenile European starlings. PLoS One 10:e0132602
Benhajali H, Richard-Yris MA, Leroux M, Ezzaouia M, Charfi F, Hausberger M (2008) A note on time budget and social behaviour of densely housed horses. A case study in Arab breeding mares. Appl Anim Behav Sci 112:196–200
Benhajali H, Richard-Yris MA, Ezzaouia M, Charfi F, Hausberger M (2009) Foraging opportunity: a crucial criterion for horse welfare? Animal 3:1308–1312
Benhajali H, Richard-Yris MA, Ezzaouia M, Charfi F, Hausberger M (2010) Reproductive status and stereotypies in breeding mares. Appl Anim Behav Sci 128:64–68
Benhajali H, Ezzaouia M, Lunel C, Charfi F, Hausberger M (2013) Temporal feeding pattern may influence reproduction efficiency, the example of breeding mares. PLoS One 8(9):e73858
Benhajali H, Ezzaouia M, Lunel C, Charfi F, Hausberger M (2014) Stereotypic behaviours and mating success in domestic mares. Appl Anim Behav Sci 153:36–42
Bethell EJ, Semple S, Holmes M, Mac Larnon A (2007) The effect of emotion state on responses to social stimuli by rhesus macaques. Primate Eye 92:5–6
Bethell EJ, Holmes A, Mac Larnon A, Semple S (2012) Cognitive bias in a non-human primate: husbandry procedures influence cognitive indicators of psychological well-being in captive rhesus macaques. Anim Welf 21(2):185–195
Boissy A, Lee C (2011) How assessing relationships between emotions and cognition can improve farm animal welfare. International Office of Epizootics 33:103–110
Boissy A, Manteuffel G, Jensen MB, Moe RO, Spruijt B, Keeling LJ, Winckler C, Forkman B, Dimitrov I, Langbein J, Bakken M, Veissier I, Aubert A (2007) Assessment of positive emotions in animals to improve their welfare. Physiol Behav 92:375–397
Briefer EF, McElligott AG (2013) Rescued goats at a sanctuary display positive mood after former neglect. Appl Anim Behav Sci 146:45–55
Briefer-Freymond S, Briefer E, Zollinger A, Allmen Y, Wyss C, Bachmann I (2014) Behaviour of horses in a judgment bias test associated with positive or negative reinforcement. Appl Anim Behav Sci 158:34–45
Brilot BO, Asher L, Bateson M (2010) Stereotyping starlings are more ‘pessimistic’. Anim Cogn 13:721–731
Broom DM (1991) Anim welfare: concepts and measurement. J Anim Sci 69:4167–4175
Burman O, Ilyat A, Jones G, Mendl M (2007) Ultrasonic vocalisations as indicators of welfare for laboratory rats (Rattus norvegicus). Appl Anim Behav Sci 104:116–129
Burman OH, Parker R, Paul ES, Mendl M (2008) A spatial judgement task to determine background emotional state in laboratory rats, Rattus norvegicus. Anim Behav 76:801–809
Burman O, McGowan R, Mendl M, Norling Y, Paul E, Rehn T, Keeling L (2011) Using judgement bias to measure positive affective state in dogs. Appl Anim Behav Sci 132:160–168
Burn CC, Dennison TL, Whay HR (2010) Relationships between behaviour and health in working horses, donkeys, and mules in developing countries. Appl Anim Behav Sci 126:109–118
Cooper J, McGreevy P (2002) Stereotypical behaviour in the stabled horse: causes, effects and prevention without compromising welfare. In: Waran N (ed) The welfare of horses. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp 99–124
Cooper JJ, McDonald L, Mills DS (2000) The effect of increasing visual horizons on stereotypic weaving: implications for the social housing of stabled horses. Appl Anim Behav Sci 69:67–83
Destrez A, Deiss V, Lévy F, Calandreau L, Lee C, Chaillou-Sagon E, Boissy A (2013) Chronic stress induces pessimistic-like judgment and learning deficits in sheep. Appl Anim Behav Sci 69:67–83
Dionne CE, Bourbonnais R, Fremont P, Rossignol M, Stock SR, Larocque I (2005) A clinical return-to-work rule for patients with back pain. Can Med Assoc J 172:1559–1567
Douglas C, Bateson M, Walsh C, Bédué A, Edwards SA (2012) Environmental enrichment induces optimistic cognitive biases in pigs. Appl Anim Behav Sci 139:65–73
Doyle RE, Fisher AD, Hinch GN, Boissy A, Lee C (2010) Release from restraint generates a positive judgement bias in sheep. Appl Anim Behav Sci 122:28–34
Doyle RE, Lee C, Deiss V, Fisher AD, Hinch GN, Boissy A (2011) Measuring judgement bias and emotional reactivity in sheep following long-term exposure to unpredictable and aversive events. Physiol Behav 102:503–510
Fonseca BPA, Alves ALG, Nicoletti JLM, Thornassian A, Hussni CA, Mikail S (2006) Thermography and ultrasonography in back pain diagnosis of equine athletes. J Equine Vet Sci 26:507–516
Fureix C, Meagher R (2015) What can inactivity reveal about affective states in non-humans? A review. Appl Anim Behav Sci 171:8–24
Fureix C, Jego P, Sankey C, Hausberger M (2009) How horses (Equus caballus) see the world: humans as significant objects. Anim Cogn 12:643–654
Fureix C, Menguy H, Hausberger M (2010) Partners with bad temper: reject or cure? A study of chronic pain and aggression in horses. PLoS One 5:e12434
Fureix C, Gorecka-Bruzda A, Gautier E, Hausberger M (2011a) Co-occurrence of yawning and stereotypic behaviour in horses Equus caballus. International Scholarly Research Notices: Zoology 10
Fureix C, Hausberger M, Sénèque E, Morisset S, Baylac M, Cornette R, Biquand V, Deleporte P (2011b) Geometric morphometrics as a tool for improving the comparative study of behavioural postures. Naturwissenschaften 98:583–592
Fureix C, Jego P, Henry S, Lansade L, Hausberger M (2012) Towards an ethological animal model of depression? A study on horses. PLoS One 7:e39280
Goodwin D, Davidson HPB, Harris P (2007) Responses of horses offered a choice between stables containing single or multiple forages. Vet Rec 160:548–551
Gordon DJ, Rogers LJ (2015) Cognitive bias, hand preference and welfare of common marmosets. Behav Brain Res 287:100–108
Haag EL, Rudman R, Houpt KA (1980) Avoidance maze learning and social dominance in ponies. J Anim Sci 50:329–335
Hales CA, Stuart SA, Anderson MH, Robinson ESJ (2014) Modelling cognitive affective biases in major depressive disorder using rodents. Brit J Pharmacol 171:4524–4538
Harding EJ, Paul ES, Mendl M (2004) Animal behaviour, cognitive bias and affective state. Nature 427:312
Harris P (2007) How should we feed horses and how many times a day? Vet J 173:9–10
Hausberger M, Muller C (2002) A brief note on some possible factors involved in the reactions of horses to humans. Appl Anim Behav Sci 76:339–344
Hausberger M, Muller C, Gautier E, Jégo P (2007) Lower learning abilities in stereotypic horses. Appl Anim Behav Sci 107:299–306
Hausberger M, Roche H, Henry S, Visser EK (2008) A review of the human-horse relationship. Appl Anim Behav Sci 109:1–24
Hausberger M, Gautier E, Biquand V, Lunel C, Jego P (2009) Could work be a source of behavioural disorders? A study in horses. PLoS One 4:e7625
Hausberger M, Muller C, Lunel C (2011) Does work affect personality? A study in horses. PLoS One 6:e14659
Hausberger M, Fureix C, Bourjade M, Wessel-Robert S, Richard-Yris MA (2012) On the significance of adult play: what does social play tell us about adult horse welfare? Naturwissenschaften 99:291–302
Hausberger M, Fureix C, Lesimple C (2016) Detecting horses’ sickness: in search of visible signs. Appl Anim Behav Sci 175:41–49
Heird JC, Lokey CE, Cogan DC (1986) Repeatability and comparison of two maze tests to measure learning ability in horses. Appl Anim Behav Sci 16:103–119
Henry S, Hemery D, Richard MA, Hausberger M (2005) Human-mare relationships and behaviour of foals toward humans. Appl Anim Behav Sci 93:341–362
Henry S, Richard-Yris MA, Hausberger M (2006) Influence of various early human-foal interferences on subsequent human-foal relationship. Dev Psychobiol 48:712–718
Hothersall B, Gale EV, Harris P, Nicol CJ (2010) Cue use by foals (Equus caballus) in a discrimination learning task. Anim Cogn 13:63–74
Jeffcott LB (1980) Disorders of the thoracolumbar spine of the horse—a survey of 443 cases. Equine Vet J 12:197–210
Keen HA, Nelson OL, Robbins CT, Evans M, Shepherdson D, Newberry RC (2013) Validation of a novel cognitive bias task based on difference in quantity of reinforcement for assessing environmental enrichment. Anim Cogn 17:529–541
Lesimple C, Fureix C, Menguy H, Hausberger M (2010) Human direct actions may alter animal welfare, a study on horses (Equus caballus). PLoS One 5:e10257
Lesimple C, Fureix C, De Margerie E, Sénèque E, Menguy H, Hausberger M (2012) Towards a postural indicator of back pain in horses (Equus caballus). PLoS One 7(9):e44604
Lesimple C, Fureix C, Biquand V, Hausberger M (2013) Comparison of clinical evaluation of back disorders and human’s evaluation of back pain in riding school horses. BMC Vet Res 9:209–217
Lesimple C, Poissonnet A, Hausberger M (2016a) How to keep your horse safe? An epidemiological study about management practices Appl Anim Behav Sci 181:105–114
Lesimple C, Fureix C, Aube L, Hausberger M (2016b) Detecting and measuring back disorders in nonverbal individuals: the example of domestic horses. Anim Behav Cogn 3:159–179
Lockener S, Reese S, Erhard M, Wohr AC (2016) Pasturing in herds after housing in horseboxes induces a positive cognitive bias in horses. J Vet Behav 11:50–55
Mal ME, Friend TH, Lay DC, Vogelsang SG, Jenkins OC (1991) Behavioural responses of mares to short-term confinement and social isolation. Appl Anim Behav Sci 31:13–24
Martin TI, Zentall TR, Lawrence L (2006) Simple discrimination reversals in the domestic horse (Equus caballus): effect of discriminative stimulus modality on learning to learn. Appl Anim Behav Sci 101:328–338
Mason GJ (1991) Stereotypies: a critical review. Anim Behav 41:1015–1037
Mason GJ, Latham NR (2004) Can’t stop, won’t stop: is stereotypy a reliable animal welfare indicator? Anim Welf 13:S57–S69
Mason GJ, Rushen J (2006) Stereotypic animal behaviour: fundamentals and application to welfare. CABI, Wallingford
Mason GJ, Clubb R, Latham N, Vickery S (2007) Why and how should we use environmental enrichment to tackle stereotypic behaviour? Appl Anim Behav Sci 102(3–4):163–188
Matheson SM, Asher L, Bateson M (2008) Larger, enriched cages are associated with ‘optimistic’ response biases in captive European starlings (Sturnus vulgaris). Appl Anim Behav Sci 109:374–383
McGreevy PD, McLean A (2005) Behavioural problems with the ridden horse. In: Mills DS, McDonnell SM (eds) The domestic horse: the origins, development and management of its behaviour. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 196–211
McGreevy PD, Cripps PJ, French NP, Green LE, Nicol CJ (1995) Management factors associated with stereotypic and redirected behavior in the thoroughbred horse. Equine Vet J 27:86–91
McLeod C, Mathews A, Tata P (1986) Attentional bias in emotional disorders. J Abnorm Psychol 95:15–20
Mendl M, Burman OHP, Parker RMA, Paul ES (2009) Cognitive bias as an indicator of animal emotion and welfare: emerging evidence and underlying mechanisms. Appl Anim Behav Sci 118:161–181
Mendl M, Brooks J, Basse C, Burman O, Paul E, Blackwell E, Casey R (2010) Dogs showing separation-related behaviour exhibit a ‘pessimistic’ cognitive bias. Curr Biol 20:839–840
Merkies K, Carson J (2011) Discrimination of water acidity by mature horses. J Equine Vet Sci 31:269
Mills DS (2005) Repetitive movement problems in the horse. In: Mills DS, McDonnell SM (eds) The domestic horse: the origins, development and management of its behaviour. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 212–227
Mostl E, Palme R (2002) Hormones as indicators of stress. Domest Anim Endocrin 23:67–74
Müller CA, Riemer S, Rosam CM, Schosswender J, Range F, Huber L (2012) Brief owner absence does not induce negative judgement bias in pet dogs. Anim Cogn 15:1031–1035
Neave HW, Daros RR, Costa JHC, von Keyserlingk MAG, Weary DM (2013) Pain and pessimism: dairy calves exhibit negative judgement bias following hot-iron. PLoS One 9(4):e96135
Nettle D, Bateson M (2012) The evolutionary origins of mood and its disorders. Curr Biol 22:712–721
Nicol CJ, Davidson HPD, Harris PA, Waters AJ, Wilson AD (2002) Study of crib-biting and gastric inflammation and ulceration in young horses. Vet Rec 151:658–662
Ninomyia S, Kusunose R, Sato S, Terada M, Sugawara K (2004) Effects of feeding methods on eating frustration in stabled horses. J Anim Sci 75:465–469
Ninomyia S, Sato S, Kusunose R, Mitumasu T, Obara Y (2007) A note on a behavioural indicator of satisfaction in stabled horses. Appl Anim Behav Sci 106:1–3
Normando S, Meers L, Samuels WE, Faustini M, Odberg FO (2011) Variables affecting the prevalence of behavioural problems in horses. Can riding style and other management factors be significant? Appl Anim Behav Sci 133:186–198
Papciak J, Popik P, Fuchs E, Rygula R (2013) Chronic psychosocial stress makes rats more ‘pessimistic’ in the ambiguous-cue interpretation paradigm. Behav Brain Res 256:305–310
Parker M, Goodwin D, Redhead ES (2008) Survey of breeders management of horses in Europe, North America and Australia: comparison of factors associated with the development of abnormal behaviour. Appl Anim Behav Sci 114:206–215
Paul ES, Harding EJ, Mendl M (2005) Measuring emotional processes in animals: the utility of a cognitive approach. Neurosci Biobehav R 29:469–491
Paul ES, Cuthill I, Kuroso G, Norton V, Woodgate J, Mendl M (2011) Mood and the speed of decisions about anticipated resources and hazards. Evol Hum Behav 32:21–28
Pincus T, Morley S (2001) Cognitive processing bias in chronic pain: a review and integration. Psychol Bull 127:599–617
Pincus T, Pearce S, Perrott A (1996) Pain patients’ bias in the interpretation of ambiguous homophones. Brit J Med Psychol 69:259–266
Pomerantz O, Terkel J, Suomi SJ, Paukner A (2012) Stereotypic head twirls, but not pacing, are related to a “pessimistic”-like judgment bias among captive tufted capuchins (Cebus apella). Anim Cogn 15:689–698
Pritchett LC, Ulibarri C, Roberts MC, Schneider RK, Sellon DC (2003) Identification of potential physiological and behavioral indicators of postoperative pain in horses after exploratory celiotomy for colic. Appl Anim Behav Sci 80:31–43
Reefmann N, Wechsler B, Gygax L (2009) Behavioural and physiological assessment of positive and negative emotion in sheep. Anim Behav 78:651–659
Rochais C, Fureix C, Lesimple C, Hausberger M (2016) Lower attention to daily environment: a novel cue for detecting chronic horses’ back pain? Scientific Reports 6:20117
Salmeto AL, Hymel KA, Carpenter EC, Brilot BO, Bateson M, Sufka KJ (2011) Cognitive bias in the chick anxiety-depression model. Brain Res 1373:124–130
Sanger ME, Doyle RE, Hinch GN, Lee C (2011) Sheep exhibit a positive judgement bias and stress-induced hyperthermia following shearing. Appl Anim Behav Sci 131:94–103
Sankey C, Richard-Yris MA, Henry S, Fureix C, Nassur F, Hausberger M (2010) Reinforcement as a mediator of the perception of humans by horses (Equus caballus). Anim Cogn 13:753–764
Schick A, Wessa M, Vollmayr B, Kuehner C, Kanske P (2013) Indirect assessment of an interpretation bias in humans: neurophysiological and behavioral correlates. Front Hum Neurosci 7:272
Siegel S, Castellan J (1988) Nonparametric statistics for the behavioral sciences, 2nd edn. McGraw-Hill, New York
Taylor JM (1987) Kendall’s and Spearman’s correlation coefficients in the presence of a blocking variable. Biometrics 43(2):409–416
Thorne JB, Goodwin D, Kennedy MJ, Davidson HPB, Harris P (2005) Foraging enrichment for individually housed horses: practicality and effects on behaviour. Appl Anim Behav Sci 94:149–164
Titulaer M, Blackwell EJ, Mendl M, Casey RA (2013) Cross sectional study comparing behavioural, cognitive and physiological indicators of welfare between short and long term kennelled domestic dogs. Appl Anim Behav Sci 147:149–158
Verbeek E, Ferguson D, Lee C (2014) Are hungry sheep more pessimistic? The effects of food restriction on cognitive bias and the involvement of ghrelin in its regulation. Physiol Behav 123:67–75
Visser EK, Ellis AD, Van Reenen CG (2008) The effect of two different housing conditions on the welfare of young horses stabled for the first time. Appl Anim Behav Sci 114:521–533
Visser K, Neijenhuis F, de Graaf-Roelfsema E, Wesselink HGM, de Boer J, van Wijhe-Kiezebrink MC, Engel B, van Reenen CG (2014) Risk factors associated with health disorders in sport and leisure horses in the Netherlands. J Anim Sci 92:844–855
Von Borstel UK, Duncan IJH, Shoveller AK, Merkies K, Keeling LJ, Millman ST (2009) Impact of riding in a coercively obtained Rollkur posture on welfare and fear of performance horses. Appl Anim Behav Sci 116:228–236
Waring G (2003) Horse behavior, 2nd edn. Noyes/William Andrew Publishing, Norwich
Wichman A, Keeling LJ, Forkman B (2012) Cognitive bias and anticipatory behaviour of laying hens housed in basic and enriched pens. Appl Anim Behav Sci 140:62–69
Wolff A, Hausberger M, LeScolan N (1997) Experimental tests to assess emotionality in horses. Behav Process 40:209–221
Acknowledgements
The authors thank the owners and staff of the riding schools, the University of Rennes 1, the CNRS and a private owner for allowing us to work with their horses and for their cooperation. We are also very grateful to Jamie Ahloy Dallaire (University of Guelph) for his help on statistics and Ann Cloarec for her revision of the English text. This study was supported by the French National Ministry for Education and Research and the French Horse and Riding Institute (IFCE).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by: Stano Pekar
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Henry, S., Fureix, C., Rowberry, R. et al. Do horses with poor welfare show ‘pessimistic’ cognitive biases?. Sci Nat 104, 8 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00114-016-1429-1
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00114-016-1429-1