Imitation and local enhancement: Detrimental effects of consensus definitions on analyses of social learning in animals

doi:10.1016/j.beproc.2013.07.026

Behavioural Processes

Volume 100, November 2013, Pages 123-130

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beproc.2013.07.026 Get rights and content

Highlights

•
Questions the usefulness of Thorndike's definition of imitation in analyzing animal traditions.
•
Questions the usefulness of the two-action method in demonstrating imitation.
•
Proposes that future studies of imitation use bird-song learning as a model paradigm.
•
Points to serious deficiencies in past research on non-imitative forms of social learning.

Abstract

Development of a widely accepted vocabulary referring to various types of social learning has made important contributions to decades of progress in analyzing the role of socially acquired information in the development of behavioral repertoires. It is argued here that emergence of a consensus vocabulary, while facilitating both communication and research, has also unnecessarily restricted research on social learning. The article has two parts. In the first, I propose that Thorndike, 1898, Thorndike, 1911 definition of imitation as “learning to do an act from seeing it done” has unduly restricted studies of the behavioral processes involved in the propagation of behavior. In part 2, I consider the possibility that success in labeling social learning processes believed to be less cognitively demanding than imitation (e.g. local and stimulus enhancement, social facilitation, etc.) has been mistaken for understanding of those processes, although essentially nothing is known of their stimulus control, development, phylogeny or substrate either behavioral or physiological.

Section snippets

Edward Thorndike and the definition of imitation

Thorndike, 1898, Thorndike, 1911 two classic monographs, both entitled Animal Intelligence and both discussing the implications of the results of his doctoral research, are often read as concerned with the outcomes of a series of experimental investigations of imitation in animals. However, it is important to note that Thorndike did not undertake his thesis to study imitation per se. Rather, Thorndike's goal was to challenge the notion, widely held during the late 19th century (e.g. Romanes,

Part 2: understanding cognitively less demanding social learning

Although for many years many laboratories have examined instances of social learning that are the result of local enhancement, social facilitation, stimulus enhancement, goal emulation, etc. (e.g. Fragaszy and Visalberghi, 1990, Galef and Clark, 1971b, Laland and Plotkin, 1990, Tomasello et al., 1987), such processes have rarely been treated as phenomena worthy of analysis in their own right. Consensus as to the definition of types of social learning believed to reflect cognitive processes less

Conclusion

More than 125 years have passed since George Romanes (1884) observed his coachman's cat open a garden gate and interpreted the cat's behavior as a product of imitation. In intervening decades, extraordinary progress has been made in describing possible mechanisms of social learning, formally modeling social learning processes and understanding the role of social learning in the development of behavioral repertoires of free-living animals. Consensus as to the definition of terms describing

Acknowledgements

I thank Clive Wynne for the invitation to contribute to submit a review paper to Behavioral Processes, Kevin Laland and Elizabeth Lonsdorf and particularly Celia Heyes and Tom Zentall for constructive responses to earlier drafts of this manuscript and Andy Whiten, Tom Zentall and Debbie Constance for feedback on an oral presentation in which much of the material in the present article was presented.

References (68)

R.W. Byrne
Imitation of novel actions: what does the evidence from animals mean?
Advances in the Study of Behavior
(2002)
D.K. Campbell-Meiklejohn et al.
How the opinion of others affects our valuation of objects
Current Biology
(2010)
B.B. Chapman et al.
Schooling and learning: early social environment predicts social learning ability in the guppy, Poecilia reticulata
Animal Behaviour
(2008)
S. Coussi-Korbel et al.
On the relation between social dynamics and social learning
Animal Behaviour
(1995)
B.V. Dawson et al.
Observational learning in budgerigars
Animal Behaviour
(1965)
P. Dayan et al.
Reward, motivation and reinforcement learning
Neuron
(2002)
M. Enquist et al.
One cultural parent makes no culture
Animal Behaviour
(2010)
B.G. Galef et al.
Imitation learning in budgerigars: Dawson and Foss (1965) revisited
Behavioral Processes
(1986)
G.S. Helfman et al.
Social transmission of behavioural traditions in a reef fish
Animal Behaviour
(1984)
C.M. Heyes
Imitation, culture and cognition
Animal Behaviour
(1993)

C.M. Heyes et al.

What is the significance of imitation in animals?

Advances in the Study of Behavior

(2000)

W. Hoppitt et al.

Social processes influencing learning in animals: a review of the evidence

Advances in the Study of Behavior

(2008)

V.M. Janik et al.

Vocal learning in mammals

Advances in the Study of Behavior

(1997)

A. Whiten et al.

On the nature and evolution of imitation in the animal kingdom: reappraisal of a century of research

Advances in the Study of Behavior

(1992)

R. Anonymous

What are the roots of culture?

Science

(2005)

C.K. Atkins et al.

Imitative learning in male Japanese quail (Coturnix japonica) involving the two-action method

Journal of Comparative Psychology

(1996)

N. Atton et al.

Information flow through threespine stickleback networks without social transmission

Proceedings of the Royal Society B

(2012)

S.A. Barnett

Experiments on ``neophobia'' in wild and laboratory rats

British Journal of Psychology

(1958)

R. Boyd et al.

Why culture is common but cultural evolution is rare

Proceedings of the British Academy

(1996)

M.S. Brainard et al.

What songbirds teach us about learning

Nature

(2002)

R.W. Byrne

The Thinking Ape: Evolutionary Origins of Intelligence

(1995)

C.A. Caldwell et al.

Studying cumulative cultural evolution in the laboratory

Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B

(2008)

I. Coolen et al.

Species difference in adaptive use of public information in sticklebacks

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B

(2003)

F.B.M. De Waal

The Ape and the Sushi Master

(2001)

J. Fisher et al.

The opening of milk bottles by birds

British Birds

(1949)

L. Fogassi et al.

Parietal lobe: from action organization to intention understanding

Science

(2005)

D.M. Fragaszy et al.

Social processes affecting the appearance of innovative processes in capuchin monkeys

Folia Primatologica

(1990)

B.G. Galef

.Differences in the affiliative behavior of weanling rats seeking eating and drinking sites

Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology

(1978)

B.G. Galef

Diving for food: analysis of a possible case of social learning in rats (Rattus norvegicus)

Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology

(1980)

B.G. Galef

The development of olfactory control of feeding-site selection in rat pups

Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology

(1981)

B.G. Galef

Imitation in animals: history, definition and interpretation of data from the psychological laboratory

B.G. Galef

The question of animal culture

Human Nature

(1992)

B.G. Galef et al.

Social factors in the poison avoidance and feeding behavior of wild and domesticated rat pups

Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology

(1971)

B.G. Galef et al.

Parent-offspring interactions determine the time and place of first ingestion of food by wild rat pups

Psychonomic Science

(1971)

Cited by (40)

Opportunities (and challenges) in dairy cattle cognition research: A key area needed to design future high welfare housing systems
2022, Applied Animal Behaviour Science
The ability of dairy cattle to adapt to husbandry systems and management routines is crucial for ensuring higher welfare and efficient production. However, this ability can be compromised by our limited knowledge of their cognitive abilities, which may result in suboptimal husbandry and management standards. In this narrative review, we highlight three topics of cattle cognition research that are currently understudied, and yet key to developing future high welfare dairy cattle housing systems: 1) transmission of information from cow to calf, 2) mechanisms to attenuate fear, and 3) cognitive processes involved in the human-cattle relationship. We review the currently available literature on all three topics and highlight promising research areas from an animal husbandry point of view. We conclude that future studies should focus on elucidating what, and how much, calves learn from their dam during prolonged cow-calf contact in dairy cattle systems. Such information could constitute an important part of the discussion of whether to keep cows and calves together for a longer time after calving in the dairy industry. Fear in the cattle group might be lowered by the use of calm companions and future studies could uncover if attenuation of fear might even be induced by conditioning positive experiences of cattle with unrelated stimuli such as odours. Lastly, the human-cattle relationship might benefit from utilising the already established training regimes from other species, for example positive reinforcement training or target training, which may have the potential to decrease risk of injury during handling for both the cow and the handler.
Emotional contagion and prosocial behavior in rodents
2022, Trends in Cognitive Sciences
Citation Excerpt :
Even if proximity seeking were therefore not primarily motivated by a prosocial motivation to console, it may still increase the likelihood of other prosocial behaviors. This is similar to how stimulus enhancement, the fact that animals will pay more attention to objects manipulated by others, is not true imitation but can still facilitate it [131]. Interestingly, proximity seeking and allogrooming are triggered by brain structures also involved in emotional contagion, including the central [109] and medial amygdala [117,119], area 24 [115,117,120,121,128], and insular cortex [113,117,132], and this activity is often modulated by the oxytocin system [115,117,120].
Empathy is critical to adjusting our behavior to the state of others. The past decade dramatically deepened our understanding of the biological origin of this capacity. We now understand that rodents robustly show emotional contagion for the distress of others via neural structures homologous to those involved in human empathy. Their propensity to approach others in distress strengthens this effect. Although rodents can also learn to favor behaviors that benefit others via structures overlapping with those of emotional contagion, they do so less reliably and more selectively. Together, this suggests evolution selected mechanisms for emotional contagion to prepare animals for dangers by using others as sentinels. Such shared emotions additionally can, under certain circumstances, promote prosocial behavior.
On the psychological origins of tool use
2022, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews
The ubiquity of tool use in human life has generated multiple lines of scientific and philosophical investigation to understand the development and expression of humans’ engagement with tools and its relation to other dimensions of human experience. However, existing literature on tool use faces several epistemological challenges in which the same set of questions generate many different answers. At least four critical questions can be identified, which are intimately intertwined—(1) What constitutes tool use? (2) What psychological processes underlie tool use in humans and nonhuman animals? (3) Which of these psychological processes are exclusive to tool use? (4) Which psychological processes involved in tool use are exclusive to Homo sapiens? To help advance a multidisciplinary scientific understanding of tool use, six author groups representing different academic disciplines (e.g., anthropology, psychology, neuroscience) and different theoretical perspectives respond to each of these questions, and then point to the direction of future work on tool use. We find that while there are marked differences among the responses of the respective author groups to each question, there is a surprising degree of agreement about many essential concepts and questions. We believe that this interdisciplinary and intertheoretical discussion will foster a more comprehensive understanding of tool use than any one of these perspectives (or any one of these author groups) would (or could) on their own.
Learned components of courtship: A focus on postural displays, choreographies and construction abilities
2022, Advances in the Study of Behavior
Citation Excerpt :
Action imitation has a long history of investigation mainly among psychologists and cognitive biologists, with steady methodological improvements which could be applied to courtship learning studies. In particular, the best method to test whether animals learn gestural elements and movement choreographies of a model would be to adopt the two-action test (Galef, 2013), with two groups of inexperienced observers exposed to two different models with clearly different courtship patterns. Using construction abilities as a study system for investigating imitation in courtship seems particularly promising.
Research into learning of courtship behavior remains largely confined to birdsong and vocal learning studies. Yet, visually communicated aspects of courtship displays are widespread and prominent, and also deserve consideration. Postural displays, choreographies, and construction of display arenas are all visual signal components mediated by motor activity of the displayer. The goal of this review is to present growing evidence for learning of courtship motor patterns other than song. We tackle two main challenges: we first highlight criteria that can be used to determine whether visual courtship components are learned, and if so, we then assess the type of learning involved. In line with the vocal learning literature, we suggest applying a distinction between usage learning and production learning of motor patterns: usage learning refers to a change in the context in which pre-existing display patterns are used, whereas production learning involves modification in trait structure, i.e. the acquisition of novel display patterns from a model. The effects of imitation, social feedback, and practice are described in detail, drawing on multiple examples from birdsong research. Our goals are to illustrate the learning processes which may affect motor development of courtship signals, to formulate testable predictions for each learning category and related mechanisms, and to suggest possible lines for future research. Although most of the evidence we review here is indirect and not yet conclusive about learning, recent technological advances now provide novel tools to quantify courtship motor patterns, and thus have the potential to produce more direct insights into whether, and how, courtship displays are learned.
The cognitive science of technology
2021, Trends in Cognitive Sciences
Technology is central to human life but hard to define and study. This review synthesizes advances in fields from anthropology to evolutionary biology and neuroscience to propose an interdisciplinary cognitive science of technology. The foundation of this effort is an evolutionarily motivated definition of technology that highlights three key features: material production, social collaboration, and cultural reproduction. This broad scope respects the complexity of the subject but poses a challenge for theoretical unification. Addressing this challenge requires a comparative approach to reduce the diversity of real-world technological cognition to a smaller number of recurring processes and relationships. To this end, a synthetic perceptual-motor hypothesis (PMH) for the evolutionary–developmental–cultural construction of technological cognition is advanced as an initial target for investigation.
Replication and emergence in cultural transmission
2019, Physics of Life Reviews
Citation Excerpt :
The copying fidelity attained by adults may not be as high as that attained by children. Adults learning a second language rarely achieve a perfect native accent, and other skills that require great motor accuracy such as skiing and tai chi (see [80]) may be more difficult to acquire and require much more time, effort or instruction, when learned as an adult than as a child. This difficulty experienced by adults could be related to sensitive periods for very early motor learning, when the machinery for replication is developing, or to the interference of already-learned actions.
Humans are fundamentally defined by our socially transmitted, often long-lived, sophisticated cultural traits. The nature of cultural transmission is the subject of ongoing debate: while some emphasize that it is a biased, transformational process, others point out that high-fidelity transmission is required to explain the quintessentially cumulative nature of human culture. This paper integrates both views into a model that has two main components: First, actions – observable motor-behavioural patterns – are inherited with high fidelity, or replicated, when they are copied, largely independently of their normal, effective or conventional function, by naive learners. Replicative action copying is the unbiased transmission process that ensures the continuity of cultural traditions. Second, mental culture – knowledge, skills, attitudes and values – is not inherited directly or faithfully, but instead emerges, or develops, during usage, when individuals learn the associations between actions and their contexts and outcomes. Mental cultural traits remain stable over generations to the extent that they are informed by similar (replicated) motor patterns unfolding in similar environments. The arguments in support of this model rest on clear distinctions between inheritance and usage; between public-behavioural and private-mental culture; and between selection for fidelity and selection for function.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

ReviewImitation and local enhancement: Detrimental effects of consensus definitions on analyses of social learning in animals

Highlights

Abstract

Section snippets

Edward Thorndike and the definition of imitation

Part 2: understanding cognitively less demanding social learning

Conclusion

Acknowledgements

Advances in the Study of Behavior

Current Biology

Animal Behaviour

Animal Behaviour

Animal Behaviour

Neuron

Animal Behaviour

Behavioral Processes

Animal Behaviour

Animal Behaviour

Advances in the Study of Behavior

Advances in the Study of Behavior

Advances in the Study of Behavior

Advances in the Study of Behavior

What are the roots of culture?

Science

Imitative learning in male Japanese quail (Coturnix japonica) involving the two-action method

Journal of Comparative Psychology

Information flow through threespine stickleback networks without social transmission

Proceedings of the Royal Society B

Experiments on ``neophobia'' in wild and laboratory rats

British Journal of Psychology

Why culture is common but cultural evolution is rare

Proceedings of the British Academy

What songbirds teach us about learning

Nature

The Thinking Ape: Evolutionary Origins of Intelligence

Studying cumulative cultural evolution in the laboratory

Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B

Species difference in adaptive use of public information in sticklebacks

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B

The Ape and the Sushi Master

The opening of milk bottles by birds

British Birds

Parietal lobe: from action organization to intention understanding

Science

Social processes affecting the appearance of innovative processes in capuchin monkeys

Folia Primatologica

.Differences in the affiliative behavior of weanling rats seeking eating and drinking sites

Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology

Diving for food: analysis of a possible case of social learning in rats (Rattus norvegicus)

Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology

The development of olfactory control of feeding-site selection in rat pups

Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology

Imitation in animals: history, definition and interpretation of data from the psychological laboratory

The question of animal culture

Human Nature

Social factors in the poison avoidance and feeding behavior of wild and domesticated rat pups

Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology

Parent-offspring interactions determine the time and place of first ingestion of food by wild rat pups

Psychonomic Science

Review
Imitation and local enhancement: Detrimental effects of consensus definitions on analyses of social learning in animals